This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The Expectations Arc progress strip: ten rows of the employment deal, with row eight of ten, Development, highlighted.

The Expectations Arc: row eight of ten.

❝

"Now, here, you see, it takes all the running you can do, to keep in the same place. If you want to get somewhere else, you must run at least twice as fast as that!"

— Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking-Glass (1871)

New here? This is row eight of ten. Start with #044 and the People Expectations Framework™, both free.

Last week, row seven asked whether anyone would notice if you left: recruited, not rooted. Row three asked whether you stay employable: employable enough to leave. Row eight, the last of the relational currency, asks whether you grow here.

Ask HR whether people grow here, and you get the talent review: a nine-box grid, a high-potential list, a development plan for everyone on it.

Ask the analyst in the top-right box, and you get another answer. She was tagged high-potential three years ago. She has a mentor, a plan, a stretch project every spring. She has the same job. When the role she was being prepared for opened in June, it went to an external hire.

Lewis Carroll gave the Red Queen the line above in 1871. Alice has been running as hard as she can, and the trees around her have not moved. That is development without a destination: all the running, the same place. Row eight measures that distance: between the training catalogue and the next role.

The framework states the expectation plainly: to be invested in, through skills, progression and mobility. And it names two tests: whether development opportunities exist, and whether progression follows skill rather than tenure.

So here is my position, before the evidence: most organisations develop people for the job they already have. People judge development by where it led, not by what it cost.

Expectation first, experience second, and then the question no talent review asks: where did it lead?

— Tanguy

This week's content

Row eight, read four ways: what people expect from a career, how progression is decided, who leaves for growth, and when development support keeps people. Then the eighth Expectation Gap: a self-audit and five metrics.

🎯 WHAT PEOPLE EXPECT 🎯 | Workmonitor 2026 | Randstad (2026) | Does anyone still want a career ladder? Randstad surveyed more than 27,000 workers and 1,225 employers in 35 markets. 72% of employers say the traditional linear career, one company with regular promotions, is outdated. Workers are split almost evenly: 41% still want that path, 38% would rather move across roles and sectors. Employers have retired the ladder. Nobody has retired the wish to climb.

⚖️ WHAT PEOPLE GET ⚖️ | Global Talent Trends 2026 | Mercer (2026) | Does progression follow skill? Mercer surveyed 9,250 employees in 16 geographies in September and October 2025. 46% say progression tends to be based on tenure, not skills. Only 26% say lateral moves are common where they work, and 32% say their company knows they could handle a more complex or senior role. The skills agenda is in every strategy deck. The promotion committee still checks the calendar.

🚪 WHO LEAVES FOR GROWTH 🚪 | Talent Outlook 2026 | Universum (2026) | Why do people leave? In Universum's global talent survey, 43% of professionals want to change employers within a year, the highest share in at least six years. Those planning to leave rate career growth higher than those staying (53% against 43%), the widest gap of any attribute. Meanwhile, more leaders now rate their internal mobility as poor, while growth remains a favourite promise in their employer value propositions. People do the arithmetic. Leaving looks like the faster way up.

🔬 WHEN DEVELOPMENT KEEPS PEOPLE 🔬 | Organizational Support for Development: The Critical Role of Career Opportunities | Journal of Applied Psychology (2011) | Does development support keep people? Maria Kraimer and four colleagues studied 264 professional employees and their supervisors. Development support lifted performance only when people saw career opportunities inside the organisation. On turnover, the effect reversed: with opportunities in view, more development support went with fewer leavers; without them, it went with more. Development is not the risk. A development plan with no road at the end of it is.

The Expectation Gap: row eight

❝

76% can grow toward their goals here. 62% can move to reach them.

ManpowerGroup, 2026

Here is the figure for your next people review, and four things it tells you.

Growth is offered; the route is withheld. Among Universum's would-be leavers, no attribute sets them apart from those staying more than career growth. That is the expectation. Now the experience. ManpowerGroup asked 13,918 workers in 19 countries two questions, side by side. Do you have enough opportunities to gain the skills and experience your career goals need? 76% said yes. Do you have enough opportunities for promotion or movement to reach those goals? 62% said yes. Read the two together, and one thing is certain: at least one worker in seven has been given the means to grow and no place to go. That is a floor; the real share could be more than twice as high.

Grouped bar chart from ManpowerGroup's Global Talent Barometer 2026. All workers: 76% have opportunities to grow toward their career goals, 62% have opportunities to move. Executives: 88% and 83%. Essential front-line workers: 65% and 46%.

Growth offered, movement offered: same respondents, three groups. The distance between each pair is the minimum share who can grow but cannot move: at least 1 in 7 overall, 1 in 20 among executives, 1 in 5 on the front line. ManpowerGroup Global Talent Barometer 2026.

Growth is rationed from the bottom. Among executives and senior managers, 88% see the growth and 83% see the move. Among essential front-line workers, it is 65% and 46%. The catalogue is open to everyone. The route is not.

Progression still runs on the clock, and it costs you twice. WorldatWork shows the first cost. Among the 1,316 professionals it surveyed, most of them in HR, career development is the reward they are least satisfied with (50%) and the strongest predictor of who stays: the dissatisfied are about 1.9 times as likely to say they are extremely unlikely to stay. Yet only about one employee in five names career advancement as a top reason to stay. People rarely name growth as the reason they stay. Its absence is what predicts that they leave. Then you pay again: in an investment bank's records, Bidwell found external hires paid about 18% more than people promoted into the same jobs, and rated lower for two years. Picture the analyst from the top-right box in July, showing the new hire where everything is.

Name the next move. Then look inside first. Grant the strongest objection: the pyramid narrows, and not everyone can be promoted. True, which is why the move need not be up. A lateral step, a project in another team, a bigger scope: Mercer finds only 26% see lateral moves as common. The cheapest route is the least used. Call it the Next-Move Rule. Every development plan names one next move, with the date it will be reviewed. Show every open role to internal candidates before it goes outside, and the panel asks for evidence of skill, not years in grade. The one-move-per-plan rule is mine, not a research finding. Then say it in the deal: we will tell you where your development leads, and we will look inside before we look outside.

People judge development by where it led, not by what it cost. A course does not take them there. A move does.

Your turn. What did the last stretch assignment you were given lead to? Hit reply; I read every one. And if you know a leadership team about to run its year-end talent review, forward this before the nine-box goes up on the screen.

🧭 The row-eight self-audit

Three questions for your next leadership meeting. Yes or no.

  1. Do we know what share of last year's open roles went to internal candidates, by level?

  2. For last year's promotions, could we show the skills evidence behind each decision, and not only the time in grade?

  3. Do we compare promotion and internal-move rates for our front-line, part-time and over-50 colleagues with everyone else's?

Three "no" answers mean your development strategy is a training catalogue. The five metrics below show where development leads, and for whom.

📏 Five metrics for row eight

No new inventions: two validated measures and three counts from your HR system, read together rather than one by one.

  1. Perceived career opportunity. The measure Kraimer, Seibert, Wayne, Liden & Bravo (2011) used: do people see attractive career opportunities inside the organisation? This condition determines whether development support keeps people or prepares them to leave. Read it by level, tenure and contract. No public benchmark; ManpowerGroup's single item (62%) is the nearest reference.

  2. Career growth, split in two. The organisational career growth scale (Weng, McElroy, Morrow & Liu, 2010) measures professional ability development and promotion speed as separate dimensions. The distance between the two is row eight's gap, inside one instrument and one person. No public benchmark; track your own trend.

  3. Internal fill rate, by level. From HR data: the share of open roles filled by internal candidates, with promotions and lateral moves counted separately, because Bidwell found they perform differently. This measures the Next-Move Rule. I know of no benchmark I would vouch for.

  4. Tenure at promotion. From HR data: time in grade at the moment of promotion, set against the skills assessment for the same people. If time in grade predicts promotion better than assessed skill, Mercer's 46% describes you. This tests the thesis.

  5. Exits after development. From HR data: voluntary exits within twelve months of completing a major programme or qualification, split by whether the person moved or was promoted afterwards. Kraimer's finding, and Benson, Finegold and Mohrman's before it, tested in your own organisation.

🎶 Mixtape Monday

Fast Car — Tracy Chapman (1988). At Wembley in June 1988, Chapman had already played her short set when Stevie Wonder's equipment went missing. The organisers sent her back on with an acoustic guitar, and this time she played Fast Car. Within weeks, it was a top-ten hit in the United States. The talent had been there all along. It took someone to put her on the main stage. That is row eight: developed, then deployed. Tomorrow on LinkedIn: the song, and the Next-Move Rule.

Next week — #053

🧩 Row nine: Meaningful work — Sunday 29 November

Row eight asks whether your development leads somewhere. Row nine asks whether the work you do today uses what you are good at. Next week, we open the ideological currency with the ninth Expectation Gap: the distance between being busy and being used.

Ten rows, ten Sundays. In December, subscribers receive the complete Expectation Gap: all ten rows in one workbook, with the questions and five metrics for every row. Stay for the set.

— Tanguy

Mini-lexicon

Developed, not deployed — the row-eight finding: organisations invest in people's growth far more readily than they put it to use in a new role, whether up, across or into a new project. This edition's frame.

The Next-Move Rule — one named role, project or lateral step written into every development plan, with a review date, and internal candidates seen before external ones. The row-eight lever.

Perceived career opportunity — whether people see attractive career opportunities inside the organisation. Kraimer and colleagues' evidence: it decides whether development support keeps people or speeds their exit.

The Expectation Gap (row eight) — the distance between "to be invested in: skills, progression, mobility" and what people judge they get: whether development opportunities exist, and whether progression follows skill rather than tenure. This edition's measure.

Meaningful work — the expectation that my work matters, uses what I am good at, and is mine to shape. Read next Sunday as the gap between being busy and being used. Row nine.

Method

The Expectation Gap sits inside the People Centricity Methodology™: Empathise, Strategise, Realise, Analyse. It is Empathise made measurable, the first two links of the People Centricity Formula™, read one row at a time.

References

Benson, G. S., Finegold, D., & Mohrman, S. A. (2004). You paid for the skills, now keep them: Tuition reimbursement and voluntary turnover. Academy of Management Journal, 47(3), 315–331. https://doi.org/10.5465/20159584

Bidwell, M. (2011). Paying more to get less: The effects of external hiring versus internal mobility. Administrative Science Quarterly, 56(3), 369–407. https://doi.org/10.1177/0001839211433562

Carroll, L. (1871). Through the looking-glass, and what Alice found there. Macmillan.

Dulac, T. (2026, September). People Expectations Framework™. PeopleCentriX. https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-expectations-framework

Kraimer, M. L., Seibert, S. E., Wayne, S. J., Liden, R. C., & Bravo, J. (2011). Antecedents and outcomes of organizational support for development: The critical role of career opportunities. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96(3), 485–500. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021452

ManpowerGroup. (2026). Global talent barometer 2026: Report and key findings. ManpowerGroup. https://www.manpowergroup.com/en/insights/talent-barometer

Mercer. (2026). Global talent trends 2026: Driving exponential performance: Solving the human-machine equation. Mercer. https://www.mercer.com/insights/people-strategy/future-of-work/global-talent-trends/

Randstad. (2026). Workmonitor 2026: The great workforce adaptation. Randstad N.V. https://www.randstad.com/workmonitor/

Universum. (2026). Talent outlook 2026: Data-driven insights and predictions for the next year, and a roadmap for employer branding success in 2026. Universum. https://universumglobal.com/resources/e-book/talent-outlook-2026-ebook

Weng, Q., McElroy, J. C., Morrow, P. C., & Liu, R. (2010). The relationship between career growth and organizational commitment. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 77(3), 391–400. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2010.05.003

WorldatWork, HRCI, & ITLN. (2026). The 2026 state of rewards. WorldatWork. https://worldatwork.org/research/state-of-rewards-2026

Explore our themed collections: a curated selection of current and past articles on our website.

Join 15,000+ professionals: follow me on LinkedIn for daily insights.

WeAreHuman@Work — Work with Purpose · © 2026 PeopleCentriX